Consensus — Final Results

Wednesday, November 4, 2026 · settled against the official Equibase charts · the consensus four as displayed under the scratch-backfill rule
Races final: 31 of 39
Winner in the consensus four: 22 of 31 (71.0%) · by rank — #1: 7 · #2: 7 · #3: 5 · #4: 3
Selection (consensus leader): 7 wins · $2 win book $62.00 staked → $34.68 returned · ROI -44.1%
$2 on each of the four: $248.00 staked → $195.52 returned · ROI -21.2%
Payoff gaps: 0 (a final race with no published winner payoff counts $0 returned)
Finger Lakes — Race 112:10 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $4.76
1#3Start the Day SELECTION16 pts1st · $4.76
2#5By Mink Standards13 pts3rd · $4.16
3#4Tony Hooks11 pts2nd · $5.96
4#6Call Saul6 pts—
Finger Lakes — Race 212:38 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $3.96
1#2Doc Advantage SELECTION18 pts1st · $3.96
2#3Hunters Ghost11 pts—
3#6Limit Up8 pts2nd · $2.76
4#4Paint the Line5 pts—
Mahoning Valley — Race 212:43 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $3.40
1#5Hot Ice SELECTION16 pts1st · $3.40
2#6Halley's Comet12 pts—
3#3Kukuk7 pts3rd · $2.20
4#1Divineness7 pts—
Churchill Downs — Race 11:00 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #3 · $2 win paid $6.22
1#3Divine Truth SELECTION14 pts—
2#2Ez Pal12 pts—
3#5Braums Run9 pts1st · $6.22
4#1Detention4 pts3rd · $3.86
Finger Lakes — Race 31:06 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #4 · $2 win paid $21.32
1#2Purpose SELECTION14 pts3rd · $2.22
2#5Little Finch12 pts2nd · $4.42
3#4Straca9 pts—
4#3Rose Lisa0 pts1st · $21.32
Churchill Downs — Race 21:29 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #2 · $2 win paid $4.14
1#5Thea SELECTION19 pts3rd · $2.72
2#2Tiffany Twist11 pts1st · $4.14
3#8Spotty Showers10 pts—
4#1Fugitive Star3 pts—
Mahoning Valley — Race 41:39 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: outside the four · $2 win paid $10.80
1#2Holiday Musical SELECTION16 pts—
2#3Renewed15 pts3rd · $2.10
3#6Moody River4 pts—
4#7Fortheloveofbonnie4 pts2nd · $2.60
Parx Racing — Race 51:53 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $3.20
1#7Never Sway SELECTION25 pts1st · $3.20
2#5Moor Strength6 pts—
3#1Laugh Like Lucy3 pts—
4#6Zeena Swift2 pts2nd · $8.20
Churchill Downs — Race 31:58 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: outside the four · $2 win paid $14.12
1#1Southern Whisper SELECTION13 pts—
2#3Lifes Reward15 pts—
3#4Stakeholder13 pts—
4#6Max Is Him7 pts2nd · $4.06
Parx Racing — Race 62:20 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #2 · $2 win paid $3.20
1#5Just Another Ten SELECTION15 pts2nd · $2.60
2#2The Magic Speed15 pts1st · $3.20
3#1Chance On Me10 pts—
4#4Zamirzo3 pts—
Churchill Downs — Race 42:27 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $6.24
1#4Belle Ofthe Dance SELECTION17 pts1st · $6.24
2#6Winning Matters15 pts2nd · $3.84
3#2Tanya's Momentum4 pts—
4#1I'm a Little Crazy3 pts—
Horseshoe Indianapolis — Race 32:36 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #4 · $2 win paid $30.20
1#7Purdy Darn Good SELECTION11 pts—
2#4Speed Bias10 pts3rd · $2.20
3#6Boitano5 pts—
4#3Mowins2 pts1st · $30.20
Parx Racing — Race 72:47 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: outside the four · $2 win paid $7.40
1#5Lasso SELECTION13 pts—
2#3Chris's Revenge12 pts—
3#6Yahoo Omar9 pts3rd · $6.40
4#4Lotsa Trouble3 pts—
Finger Lakes — Race 73:01 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: outside the four · $2 win paid $14.74
1#8Lady Serenity SELECTION20 pts—
2#1Timely Reward14 pts—
3#5Miss Stones8 pts2nd · $3.72
4#4Open Soul Autism6 pts3rd · $2.80
Mahoning Valley — Race 73:03 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #3 · $2 win paid $11.60
1#4Tipsy Tulip SELECTION13 pts—
2#3Illuminate11 pts2nd · $2.60
3#5Coloryoureggs9 pts1st · $11.60
4#2Cinderbella1 pts—
Horseshoe Indianapolis — Race 43:07 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #3 · $2 win paid $4.60
1#9Wicked Suprise SELECTION6 pts—
2#12Tiverton3 pts2nd · $2.80
3#11Great Sword MOVES UP8 pts1st · $4.60
4#10J P Hellish MOVES UP5 pts—
Scratched from the consensus four: #6 Gagliardi, #5 Zach — #11 Great Sword, #10 J P Hellish move up in consensus order.
Parx Racing — Race 83:14 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #2 · $2 win paid $3.20
1#2Ready as Ever SELECTION14 pts2nd · $2.80
2#3Trotsky18 pts1st · $3.20
3#6America's Honor6 pts—
4#4N. Y. Finest5 pts3rd · $3.80
Finger Lakes — Race 83:30 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #2 · $2 win paid $15.08
1#7King's Leap SELECTION12 pts2nd · $2.88
2#5Zatara11 pts1st · $15.08
3#1Gunner Bay10 pts—
4#8Passioned MOVES UP— pts3rd · $2.42
Scratched from the consensus four: #3 Eldest Son — #8 Passioned move up in consensus order.
Parx Racing — Race 93:41 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: outside the four · $2 win paid $10.20
1#1Bourbon Aficionado SELECTION30 pts2nd · $3.00
2#2Roxton6 pts—
3#8Home Invasion4 pts—
4#5Fully Committed0 pts—
Churchill Downs — Race 73:55 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $8.52
1#3Comprehensive SELECTION13 pts1st · $8.52
2#9Ryu MOVES UP6 pts—
3#7Kelz MOVES UP1 pts3rd · $2.30
4#12Safety Off MOVES UP0 pts2nd · $7.58
Scratched from the consensus four: #5 Ocelli, #15 Veblen, #6 Mayfield — #9 Ryu, #7 Kelz, #12 Safety Off move up in consensus order.
Horseshoe Indianapolis — Race 64:10 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $4.60
1#7Campaign Promises SELECTION13 pts1st · $4.60
2#5Lady of Sky2 pts—
3#6Lalily1 pts2nd · $4.40
4#2Miss Saipan MOVES UP— pts—
Scratched from the consensus four: #3 Botox Katie — #2 Miss Saipan move up in consensus order.
Churchill Downs — Race 84:25 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: outside the four · $2 win paid $10.10
1#3Freaks Go SELECTION25 pts3rd · $2.10
2#5Scythia12 pts—
3#1Transatlantic3 pts—
4#6Tearin'up My Heart0 pts—
Churchill Downs — Race 94:55 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #2 · $2 win paid $13.08
1#4Clairita SELECTION14 pts—
2#5Being Myself7 pts1st · $13.08
3#10Shilling7 pts2nd · $4.76
4#8Ile de La Cite0 pts—
Horseshoe Indianapolis — Race 85:15 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: outside the four · $2 win paid $13.80
1#6Munny Town SELECTION17 pts3rd · $2.40
2#10Bramble Blaze9 pts2nd · $9.00
3#8Big Commerce8 pts—
4#7Frosty the Soldier6 pts—
Delta Downs — Race 26:08 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #3 · $2 win paid $3.40
1#10Take This City SELECTION12 pts3rd · $4.20
2#5Perfect Timing11 pts2nd · $5.20
3#8Candy Dreamin9 pts1st · $3.40
4#9Justice for Johnny2 pts—
Penn National — Race 26:14 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #4 · $2 win paid $19.00
1#4Tortuga Island SELECTION27 pts3rd · $2.80
2#3Cheekiest9 pts—
3#1Vicountess5 pts—
4#5Keep It Safe3 pts1st · $19.00
Charles Town — Race 17:00 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: outside the four · $2 win paid $24.20
1#4Hill Country SELECTION23 pts—
2#5Scar Nose10 pts3rd · $7.60
3#1Now Teddy6 pts—
4#3Mac Daddyness MOVES UP— pts—
Scratched from the consensus four: #6 Ojin — #3 Mac Daddyness move up in consensus order.
Mountaineer — Race 17:00 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: outside the four · $2 win paid $22.00
1#5Calling On Heaven SELECTION15 pts—
2#6Axcel7 pts3rd · $2.80
3#3A Ok MOVES UP10 pts2nd · $5.20
4#9Ozzy MOVES UP5 pts—
Scratched from the consensus four: #13 Tail Risk, #12 Before and After — #3 A Ok, #9 Ozzy move up in consensus order.
Penn National — Race 47:12 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #2 · $2 win paid $7.20
1#2Trophy Room SELECTION19 pts—
2#3Ellie's Boyfriend13 pts1st · $7.20
3#4Genghis8 pts2nd · $3.00
4#1Eclipticals Bear0 pts—
Mountaineer — Race 27:25 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #3 · $2 win paid $9.20
1#4Lumenique SELECTION10 pts—
2#2La Heroica MOVES UP7 pts—
3#3Upscuttled MOVES UP5 pts1st · $9.20
4#7Morgan's Bluff MOVES UP0 pts2nd · $3.80
Scratched from the consensus four: #14 Mo Touring, #12 Botita, #6 True Patriot — #2 La Heroica, #3 Upscuttled, #7 Morgan's Bluff move up in consensus order.
Delta Downs — Race 57:32 PM ET · FINAL
Winner: consensus #2 · $2 win paid $9.40
1#6Red Road SELECTION10 pts—
2#5Vodka Martini8 pts1st · $9.40
3#9Ampitup MOVES UP— pts2nd · $4.00
4#1Feelthebeat MOVES UP— pts3rd · $2.20
Scratched from the consensus four: #2 Grazed, #3 My Pal Sweet — #9 Ampitup, #1 Feelthebeat move up in consensus order.
Mountaineer — Race 37:50 PM ET · NO RESULT POSTED
Not final yet
1#8Unworkable SELECTION25 pts—
2#6Speighty War8 pts—
3#4Accona2 pts—
4#2Good Moments2 pts—
Penn National — Race 68:10 PM ET · NO RESULT POSTED
Not final yet
1#1Aquitania Arrival SELECTION9 pts—
2#5Megan's Honor22 pts—
3#6Ridley Park8 pts—
4#4Harbor of Gold3 pts—
Charles Town — Race 48:25 PM ET · NO RESULT POSTED
Not final yet
1#8Genuine Gomo SELECTION17 pts—
2#4Valhalla's Palace14 pts—
3#3No Love for Juba4 pts—
4#7Cut the Cord1 pts—
Penn National — Race 78:39 PM ET · NO RESULT POSTED
Not final yet
1#6Wink of an Eye SELECTION16 pts—
2#4Atlas Strong7 pts—
3#7My Sugar Boo7 pts—
4#5Always Angels5 pts—
Charles Town — Race 58:53 PM ET · NO RESULT POSTED
Not final yet
1#8Petra Columba SELECTION15 pts—
2#7Glorify It13 pts—
3#4Sierra6 pts—
4#5Snowboarder5 pts—
Remington Park — Race 59:22 PM ET · NO RESULT POSTED
Not final yet
1#2Lil Town Sis SELECTION12 pts—
2#7Scribble13 pts—
3#1Dig Baby Dig9 pts—
4#11Rainbow Smiles5 pts—
Remington Park — Race 710:18 PM ET · NO RESULT POSTED
Not final yet
1#1Chad Allan SELECTION11 pts—
2#3Marc10 pts—
3#2Highly Connected3 pts—
4#8Old Boys Club3 pts—
Remington Park — Race 911:14 PM ET · NO RESULT POSTED
Not final yet
1#12Winged Lion SELECTION13 pts—
2#1Zorritos Dash8 pts—
3#9Dokkodo6 pts—
4#7Fair Weather Flyer5 pts—
The day's book — every pick on the card
Scratches: 3 official pick(s) were scratched in the official chart. Those legs settle on the first backup in the chain that actually ran — the other scenario's pick first, then the official pick's filed alternate, then the other scenario's alternate — and the book below counts them.
As filed (before scratches): 30 settled · 7 winners · $60 win bets → $33.48 · ROI -44.2%
Headline: 33 legs · 8 winners · W-P-S 8-5-7 · $66 win bets → $42.88 · WIN ROI -35.0%
Place bets: 33 settled · $66 place bets → $40.66 · ROI -38.4%
Show bets: 33 settled · $66 show bets → $51.74 · ROI -21.6%
Official picks: 30 settled · 8 winners · W-P-S 8-4-7 · $60 win bets → $42.88 · ROI -28.5%
Counter-move legs (§16): 3 settled · 0 winners · W-P-S 0-1-0 · $6 win bets → $0.00 · ROI -100.0%
Winner was the official pick: 8 of 30
Consensus sheet races: 30 settled · 7 winners · W-P-S 7-5-6 · $60 win bets → $35.56 · WIN ROI -40.7% · PLACE ROI -40.0% · SHOW ROI -26.6% — the picks from the 39 races printed on the day's Consensus Sheet, scored separately; a subset of the headline book above, not added to it.
In the money: 20 of 33 pick legs (61%) finished 1st, 2nd or 3rd.
The 8 winners paid an average of $5.36 on a $2 win ticket.
Across the board: $2 win-place-show on every pick — $180 → $128.74 · ROI -28.5%.
Settled editions & the full card
Part 1
Part 2a
Part 2b
Part 2c
Part 2d
Part 2e
Part 2f
Selections Results
Consensus — Settled
Full Card — Settled 1
Full Card — Settled 2
Full Card — Settled 3