Consensus — Final Results

Thursday, November 12, 2026 · settled against the official Equibase charts · the consensus four as displayed under the scratch-backfill rule

Races final: 24 of 32

Winner in the consensus four: 18 of 24 (75.0%) · by rank — #1: 11 · #2: 2 · #3: 2 · #4: 3

Selection (consensus leader): 11 wins · $2 win book $48.00 staked → $50.68 returned · ROI +5.6%

$2 on each of the four: $192.00 staked → $116.44 returned · ROI -39.4%

Payoff gaps: 0 (a final race with no published winner payoff counts $0 returned)

Mahoning Valley — Race 112:15 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $3.40

1#4Gray Day SELECTION21 pts1st · $3.40

2#2Gottomakeithappen9 pts3rd · $2.10

3#1Biscuits and Grits5 pts2nd · $3.40

4#5Fact Not Fiction — pts—

Scratched from the consensus four: #3 Gone in a Flash — #5 Fact Not Fiction move up in consensus order.

Parx Racing — Race 212:32 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: outside the four · $2 win paid $16.80

1#3Prince Colton SELECTION22 pts2nd · $4.20

2#2Ahsad17 pts—

3#6I Feelucky Tonite8 pts—

4#4Bob John Ray7 pts3rd · $2.80

Parx Racing — Race 312:59 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $6.60

1#3Vance Scholars SELECTION17 pts1st · $6.60

2#4Fast Bob8 pts3rd

3#6Traffic Master1 pts—

4#1Broadcaster — pts2nd · $2.40

Scratched from the consensus four: #5 Praetorian Guard — #1 Broadcaster move up in consensus order.

Mahoning Valley — Race 31:11 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $5.20

1#1Nacua SELECTION19 pts1st · $5.20

2#2Golden Hurricane13 pts3rd · $2.40

3#3Exodus6 pts2nd · $2.60

4#4Wonderful Quality2 pts—

Churchill Downs — Race 21:29 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $3.76

1#5Oraia SELECTION18 pts1st · $3.76

2#4Angel Bella14 pts—

3#6Full Dolly8 pts3rd · $3.40

4#1Justified Gift5 pts2nd · $3.72

Parx Racing — Race 62:20 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #4 · $2 win paid $7.80

1#1Dreaming of Gerry SELECTION18 pts3rd · $2.20

2#3Recker Point12 pts2nd · $8.40

3#6Guaponess5 pts—

4#2Silent Mode2 pts1st · $7.80

Churchill Downs — Race 42:27 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $3.16

1#3Shared Vision SELECTION30 pts1st · $3.16

2#2Getting After It8 pts3rd · $2.80

3#7Lexico2 pts—

4#5G Rocks2 pts2nd · $6.62

Horseshoe Indianapolis — Race 32:32 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: outside the four · $2 win paid $13.00

1#5Shankar SELECTION10 pts2nd · $4.60

2#12Baytown Parfait9 pts—

3#6Elevated Game6 pts3rd · $4.00

4#8Debt Paid5 pts—

Mahoning Valley — Race 62:35 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #3 · $2 win paid $5.40

1#4Little Shance SELECTION16 pts2nd · $2.40

2#6Gone Wild11 pts—

3#5Judy's Comet10 pts1st · $5.40

4#2Unbridled O'Brien7 pts—

Mahoning Valley — Race 73:03 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $6.80

1#2Carnival Rock SELECTION23 pts1st · $6.80

2#3Wild Cotton13 pts—

3#4Semper Anticus5 pts3rd · $5.40

4#7Mitochondria1 pts—

Belmont Park — Race 63:12 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #4 · $2 win paid $5.50

1#6Ganderella SELECTION17 pts3rd · $2.76

2#3Zap That Ghost16 pts—

3#1Take Charge Smarty8 pts—

4#4Vicked4 pts1st · $5.50

Parx Racing — Race 83:14 PM ET · NO RESULT POSTED

Not final yet

1#5Costa Amalfitana SELECTION19 pts—

2#6Formaggio8 pts—

3#4Chilly Girl4 pts—

4#2Prayed for Girl1 pts—

Mahoning Valley — Race 83:31 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $2.40

1#3Water Into Wine SELECTION23 pts1st · $2.40

2#6Mor Stormy11 pts3rd · $2.40

3#1Cowgirlsluvme6 pts—

4#2Skytree4 pts2nd · $5.00

Horseshoe Indianapolis — Race 53:34 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: outside the four · $2 win paid $53.20

1#12Memphis Pharoah SELECTION12 pts2nd · $4.40

2#4Mr. Funtastico4 pts—

3#3Extravagant Prince2 pts—

4#9Born Flashy 5 pts—

Scratched from the consensus four: #7 St. Armands Key — #9 Born Flashy move up in consensus order.

Belmont Park — Race 73:43 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $4.56

1#4Stand the Rain SELECTION11 pts1st · $4.56

2#2Alibi8 pts3rd · $2.52

3#5Abigail 11 pts2nd · $4.04

4#7Tiz the Lady 4 pts—

Scratched from the consensus four: #3 Toes, #6 Consensus View — #5 Abigail, #7 Tiz the Lady move up in consensus order.

Belmont Park — Race 84:14 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #2 · $2 win paid $14.06

1#1Sociably Johnny SELECTION25 pts—

2#2Whitby4 pts1st · $14.06

3#8Monte Avi2 pts3rd · $4.42

4#4Supreme Good1 pts2nd · $4.50

Churchill Downs — Race 94:55 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: outside the four · $2 win paid $92.78

1#9Son of a Birch SELECTION12 pts—

2#4Sea Singer6 pts2nd · $4.36

3#2Demolition Duke4 pts3rd · $5.88

4#10Out of Deductions4 pts—

Woodbine — Race 55:06 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: outside the four · $2 win paid $26.50

1#1Shimmering Frost SELECTION21 pts—

2#3Charming Jackie6 pts—

3#6Awesome Grace5 pts—

4#4Matoaka5 pts2nd · $5.90

Horseshoe Indianapolis — Race 95:41 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #4 · $2 win paid $16.20

1#10Alloutjustice SELECTION21 pts3rd · $4.00

2#2Soxit Toem7 pts—

3#8Wautoma Waters7 pts—

4#1Crema Agria7 pts1st · $16.20

Woodbine — Race 76:04 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: outside the four · $2 win paid $17.10

1#4Mor Joe's Spirit SELECTION17 pts—

2#5Named Firey8 pts—

3#3Lohan7 pts3rd · $5.10

4#1Flyonbye4 pts2nd · $5.10

Penn National — Race 26:14 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #3 · $2 win paid $4.80

1#5Techstar SELECTION15 pts2nd · $2.60

2#2Our Golden Gator12 pts3rd · $2.60

3#7Truthorconsequence11 pts1st · $4.80

4#4Remembrall3 pts—

Woodbine — Race 86:33 PM ET · NO RESULT POSTED

Not final yet

1#9Lemon Sweets SELECTION19 pts—

2#2Miss Brit9 pts—

3#3Spirit of Indy1 pts—

4#11Ruby's Appeal0 pts—

Delta Downs — Race 47:04 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $5.20

1#2Luv to Win SELECTION22 pts1st · $5.20

2#1Scallywag12 pts—

3#5Whiskey and Easy7 pts3rd · $3.40

4#4Julia's Warrior3 pts2nd · $3.40

Penn National — Race 47:12 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $3.80

1#2What Does It Take SELECTION21 pts1st · $3.80

2#5Bold Ambition12 pts3rd

3#1Uninvited Guest6 pts2nd · $3.60

4#3Lomax6 pts—

Remington Park — Race 17:30 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #2 · $2 win paid $12.00

1#1Love That Witch SELECTION13 pts2nd · $4.00

2#3Blackwing11 pts1st · $12.00

3#6I Rest My Case10 pts—

4#4Aunt Penny8 pts—

Penn National — Race 57:41 PM ET · FINAL

Winner: consensus #1 · $2 win paid $5.80

1#6Maximus Meridius SELECTION27 pts1st · $5.80

2#4Houghton Shuffle9 pts—

3#2Showstopper Copper8 pts3rd · $4.40

4#7Great Richie M3 pts2nd · $5.20

Charles Town — Race 37:57 PM ET · NO RESULT POSTED

Not final yet

1#5Dark Fury SELECTION18 pts—

2#3Starship Refund14 pts—

3#1Look Ahead5 pts—

4#4Police Woman1 pts—

Penn National — Race 78:39 PM ET · NO RESULT POSTED

Not final yet

1#1Gentle Breeze SELECTION22 pts—

2#4Super Tiz14 pts—

3#3Boss Holiday11 pts—

4#7Federal Exchange8 pts—

Remington Park — Race 59:22 PM ET · NO RESULT POSTED

Not final yet

1#2Storms Last SELECTION10 pts—

2#8Da Chief13 pts—

3#7Waylon's Guitar6 pts—

4#5Bobwhite Bobby1 pts—

Remington Park — Race 69:50 PM ET · NO RESULT POSTED

Not final yet

1#2Miss Code West SELECTION18 pts—

2#4La Fantastica9 pts—

3#3Talkin Cadee3 pts—

4#7Lit Up2 pts—

Remington Park — Race 710:18 PM ET · NO RESULT POSTED

Not final yet

1#6Mi Amiga SELECTION16 pts—

2#1Blingster10 pts—

3#4Golly Holly9 pts—

4#7Texas Speed Queen0 pts—

Remington Park — Race 810:46 PM ET · NO RESULT POSTED

Not final yet

1#9Cayman Hot SELECTION7 pts—

2#1Lookatthatgirlrun6 pts—

3#12Pronunciation3 pts—

4#5Shari's Magic0 pts—

The day's book — every pick on the card

As filed (before scratches): 27 settled · 13 winners · $54 win bets → $56.90 · ROI +5.4%

Headline: 27 legs · 13 winners · W-P-S 13-3-4 · $54 win bets → $56.90 · WIN ROI +5.4%

Place bets: 27 settled · $54 place bets → $45.36 · ROI -16.0%

Show bets: 27 settled · $54 show bets → $43.92 · ROI -18.7% — 2 in-the-money leg(s) had no show price in the official chart and count $0.

Official picks: 26 settled · 13 winners · W-P-S 13-3-4 · $52 win bets → $56.90 · ROI +9.4%

Counter-move legs (§16): 1 settled · 0 winners · W-P-S 0-0-0 · $2 win bets → $0.00 · ROI -100.0%

Winner was the official pick: 13 of 26

Consensus sheet races: 20 settled · 10 winners · W-P-S 10-3-3 · $40 win bets → $46.12 · WIN ROI +15.3% · PLACE ROI -5.5% · SHOW ROI -12.0% — the picks from the 32 races printed on the day's Consensus Sheet, scored separately; a subset of the headline book above, not added to it.

In the money: 20 of 27 pick legs (74%) finished 1st, 2nd or 3rd.

The 13 winners paid an average of $4.38 on a $2 win ticket.

Across the board: $2 win-place-show on every pick — $152 → $146.18 · ROI -3.8%. (2 pool stake(s) refunded — the chart printed no price for that pool.)

On the page — perfect-selection settlement

Had you picked the right horses from the four on this page every time:

In the four: winner in 22 of 26 (84.6%) · place horse in 18 · show horse in 20 · exacta in 14 · trifecta in 11 · superfecta in 0

In the four money ($2 in → returned): win $44.00 → $134.12 · exacta $28.00 → $326.34 · trifecta $20.00 → $1,080.36 · superfecta $0.00 → $0.00 · combined $92.00 → $1,540.82 (return 1674.8% · ROI +1574.8%)

In the four: 1 contained bet(s) had no chart payoff and count $0 (payoff gaps).

On the page: winner in 24 of 26 (92.3%) · place horse in 25 · show horse in 23 · exacta in 23 · trifecta in 20 · superfecta in 9

On the page money ($2 in → returned): win $48.00 → $212.40 · exacta $46.00 → $1,731.62 · trifecta $36.00 → $5,675.72 · superfecta $18.00 → $25,449.10 · combined $148.00 → $33,068.84 (return 22343.8% · ROI +22243.8%)

On the page: 2 contained bet(s) had no chart payoff and count $0 (payoff gaps).

Perfect-selection ceiling — assumes the right choice from the page every time.

Settled editions & the full card